Wednesday 6 July 2016

Review: The Scent of Water



This book is for all the single women out there. If you’ve ever been hopelessly in love with someone while knowing it could never work, if you’ve ever wondered whether there’s something wrong with you for preferring to be alone, if you’ve ever thrown a book at the wall because it provides a fairy-tale romance as the only answer to real-world problems, this book is for you.

Mary Lindsay, the heroine, is a civil servant from London who prides herself on being practical. When she inherits a cottage called The Laurels in a remote village from a distant cousin she only met once as a child, the practical thing to do would be to sell it. However, to her own surprise, Mary decides to live there instead, setting off a chain of events that will affect not only her, but everyone around her.

Mary starts out believing that she is incapable of love. The wartime death of her fiancé haunts her, not only for all the obvious reasons, but because she could not return his feelings no matter how much she respected him as a person. Similarly, she feels guilty because, even though she lost touch with Mary Sr. after their one meeting, the older woman cared enough to pass on not only her cottage, but a collection of priceless miniature treasures such a blown glass tea set and a palm-sized ivory carving. Mary Jr. comes to The Laurels with a deep-seated longing to learn more about her cousin’s life, and about the imaginative, intuitive part of herself she suppressed long ago.

This is, among other things, a book about mental illness. Mary Sr.’s diaries describe a lifelong struggle with something that we might call depression or bipolar disorder: “I can’t talk to people because this illness isn’t like other illnesses (…) I remember Mother didn’t [understand] when I was a child, and I said I was lying on stones and the black walls were moving in” (ch. 5 p. 56, e-book edition). In the absence of therapy, medication, or even a name to call her condition, she turns for support to her Christian beliefs and her reverence for home and nature: “I am seeking the goodness of God that waters the dry places (…) I shall fall into black depression, and perhaps desperation too, but it will pass and spring will come with celandines and white violets in the lanes … ” (ch. 5 p. 84). Similarly, Jean Anderson, the Vicar’s sister, relies on religion to cope with her social anxiety. In the middle of panicking about her brother’s request that she visit the newly arrived Mary Jr., she feels comforted by the idea of God laughing with her about her predicament (ch. 4 p. 48).

Elizabeth Goudge describes these characters in tones of deep respect as well as compassion: “If many of [Jean’s] fears and burdens would have seemed unreal to another woman, there was nothing unreal about her courage” (ch. 4 p. 37). She does not reduce them to their labels or overanalyze them with medical jargon, neither does she make fun of them, minimize their problems, or idealize them as saints (although, to be fair, Mary Sr.’s referring to her depressive episodes as punishment for her sins may grate on a modern reader’s nerves).

What this book conveys, and what Mary Jr. learns, is the interconnectedness of all people regardless of time and space. She can still learn from her cousin and her fiancé, even after their deaths. She can love someone and be enriched by it, whether or not that person feels the same. Among her neighbors, the mutual empathy between two war veterans grows despite their involvement with the same woman, and a wealthy landowner’s business gamble becomes his salvation as well as his ruin. The web of plotlines reaches all the way back to the construction of the local abbey during the Middle Ages, in which a disfigured monk overcame his self-loathing and suicidal thoughts, learned to carry himself confidently, became a healer, and inspired his countrymen’s spiritual lives hundreds of years after his death.


“I wasn’t solitary. Everyone was me and I was everyone” (ch. 7 p. 105). It’s not an original idea by any means, but it’s one that needs repeating.

No comments:

Post a Comment